What kind of crazy mixed-up world do we live in when Lindsey Buckingham is fired by Fleetwood Mac?
Buckingham was the architect of the sound that made Fleetwood Mac so popular starting in 1975. After all the success producing their songs, being one of three songwriters & lead vocalists, and playing lead guitar, he quit the group in 1987. He was replaced by two musicians, Billy Burnette and Rick Vito.
Then after 10 years, he rejoined Fleetwood Mac for their 1997 reunion, “The Dance”. The group has toured on and off since then, including quite a few years without Christine McVie.
This month, after disagreements about an upcoming tour, Fleetwood Mac dismissed Buckingham, and replaced him with The Heartbreaker’s lead guitarist, Mike Campbell, and Crowded House leader Neil Finn. Those are two extremely talented musicians who could actually add some new touches to Fleetwood Mac. Notice how it always takes two guys to replace Lindsey Buckingham.
Update: Some quotes in Rolling Stone tell us more.
Mick Fleetwood said about the disagreement over the fall tour…“We arrived at the impasse of hitting a brick wall. We made a decision that we could not go on with him. Majority rules in terms of what we need to do as a band.“
Stevie Nicks said Buckingham wanted to put off the tour for a year, and the band didn’t want to wait. Fleetwood Mac will be performing songs from the entire history of the band, including before Stevie and Lindsey joined. Nicks said…“We were never able to do that since 1975, because certain people in the band weren’t interested in doing that.” Nicks compared the situation to the ending of a long marriage. “We were never married, but we might as well have been. This is sad for me, but I want the next 10 years of my life to be really fun and happy.”
(Above, Fleetwood Mac with Neil Finn & Mike Campbell. Speculation about old Fleetwood Mac songs that could be done on the tour… “Black Magic Woman” [FM’s is the original version], “Oh Well”, “Albatross”, “The Green Manalishi”, and “Hypnotized”.)
I’m a fan of Lindsey Buckingham, and own most of his albums. 1992’s Out Of The Cradle is far and away my favorite by him. Unfortunately, his more recent studio albums have over-produced effects on his voice. His 2012 live album, Songs From The Small Machine, has some better versions of his later material.
We had tickets for his concert in a fairly small venue in Lincoln, Nebraska in the early 2000’s. But, when we showed up to see him, we were informed he was not satisfied with the sound system, and had canceled the show. He has a reputation for sometimes being difficult…although that might be an interpretation of his caring about doing things right.
So…now that Lindsey Buckingham is “Second Hand News”…will the new tour be a success for Fleetwood Mac? Almost certainly, yes. There’s plenty of star power with Stevie Nicks, Christine McVie, and the rest of this new line-up. Their first performance will be at a September 21st festival in Las Vegas. Then the 52 show tour starts October 3rd.
History has shown us bands are their own brands, and not all the original members are needed. Journey still draws crowds without lead singer Steve Perry. Foreigner does the same without lead singer Lou Gramm. Queen is a success without Freddie Mercury, and many more longtime bands draw crowds without various original members. Apparently, fans want to hear the hits, and “close enough” versions are accepted.
Back in the late ’80’s, I encountered the opposite phenomenon…lead singers without their bands. It was an oldies show at a county fair. Gary Lewis (without The Playboys), Dennis Yost (without The Classics Four), and Alex Chilton (without The Box Tops) all performed with the same backing band. At least we heard “This Diamond Ring”, “Traces”, and “The Letter” by the original vocalists. Because I was with the local radio stations, I had a chance to talk with the singers. Alex Chilton was the only one who didn’t really want to be there. He made it obvious he was doing it for the money, as his other critically praised group, Big Star, was never a commercial success. I certainly got the impression he would have preferred performing new music, instead of oldies.
As for Lindsey Buckingham…it seems a shame that the members of Fleetwood Mac had to “break the chain”.